Jeremy Cardash, an Israeli right-wing blogger, addresses the Jewish community on his blog, "
Israeli Stories: To all you "embarrassed Jews", by saying
It's easy to criticize Israel from afar, it's easy to be drawn in by the ludicrous, political correctness, western liberalism and, in many cases, a sense of extreme embarrassment forced on and often embraced by Jews in the Diaspora. It's easy to shout and scream and criticize, worrying what your non-Jewish neighbors or colleagues may think, becoming the ultimate apologists. It's easy to scream from your comfortable pseudo-Jewish ivory towers. What seems to be harder is for you to muster some sense of loyalty and support for your own people (Jews) and your own country ( Israel). (Just a reminder.) And there aren't enough righteous gentiles to save us all.
{...}
"So now that Israel, after months and months of restraint and in the wake of thousands of rockets, has finally returned to Gaza to deal with Hamas, you say that you are 'embarrassed' by Israel's actions?
You'll tell me I am insecure in my beliefs, that I am ultra right-wing, and that I am blinded by fanaticism. You'll tell me that you know what the problem is and what should be done.
I am not ultra right-wing, just a realist who takes the facts and history into consideration. This is not a simplistic view but a carefully considered opinion. This is not based on a persecution complex but a simple historical formula. They want us out. The President of Iran wants our total destruction. Hamas, Hizbullah, Islamic Jihad, Al Qaida are all vying for the opportunity to drive us into the sea. Many other Arab countries would love to see us gone. That's a fact."
I am not interested in any of his political views when we are witnessing over 500 Palestinian people, many of them civilians, being killed by the Israeli attacks on Gaza, but what is more important is the comments of readers to his blog. It shows some interesting perspectives that range from extreme to moderate political thinking. It reveals how Jewish and sometimes non-Jewish but Israeli-supporters think. I pasted the text as is and remove some because of space. However, entire comments are published at the
bottom of this hyperlink{...}
4 | drdan, canada, Wednesday Dec 31, 2008 I am a Diaspora Jew. I am also an Israeli. My identity has not been stolen - and I will not be lectured to about the myopia of the Middle East by someone who represents his right-wingery as "realism". Here's another dose of reality. We (if I can use "we" from "over here", sitting on the fence or whatever...) are the regional superpower. Hamas has neither the power nor the ability to destroy Israel. Hamas can make the lives of *some* Israelis utterly miserable... while others continue on with their day, working, going to school, sitting in cafes. So who's persecuting who?
5 | Marsha Katz Johns Creek, GA USA, Wednesday Dec 31, 2008 I felt my prayers were answered with Israel's stand. My distress comes from our giving up Land G-d gave us along with wrenching Jews from their homes and the loss of Jewish life. The Arab world will never allow peace so we must defend ourselves forever. No fence here. I'm an American Jew born the same year Israel became a State. I'm proud of my Judaism and Israel. They are my heart and my soul. We will never turn our backs. I am sorry you feel we are not with you... I am; we are.
6 | Siegel, Palm Beach Co., FL USA, Wednesday Dec 31, 2008 First, I'm greatful for my fellow American John in Lakeland for holding fast to the same original beliefs on which our country, USA, was founded and recognizing the same rights in other "Free" countries such as Israel. Jeremy Cardash...you are not alone!! It makes me sick to my stomach when I come across the "Embarrassed Jew" unable to stand out from the shadow of generations of our religious oppression. There are those of us jews whose fathers were not raised and did not raise their sons as "Momma's Boys" but as true men ready to stand up and fight for who they are as Jews and Americans.
7 | LIBBIE, Wednesday Dec 31, 2008 I BELIEVE ISREAL DOES HAVE THE RIGHT TO DEFEND ITSELF AND BELIEVE THE BIBLE IS GODS WORD AND HIS WORD SAYS I WILL CURSE THEM WHO CURSE YOU(ISREAL) AND BLESS THOSE WHO BLESS YOU.
8 | Proud of Israel, Thursday Jan 01, 2009 What's the overiding vision at JPost? Tie Israel to Judea and Samaria and keep the millions of people who live in these lands apart, with no rights to Israeli citizenship, and no responsibility on the part of the state to look after the welfare of those whose borders Tsahal controls. That can't work. The idea of ethnic cleansing I'll grant has worked in the past for different peoples and states, but what has -never- worked for anybody is to seek to occupy hundreds of thousands (in Israel's case millions) of people and at the same time keep them apart and unintegrated and pacified too.
9 | Proud of Israel, Thursday Jan 01, 2009 There are indeed many reasons to be proud of Israel. The overall excellent healthcare system (that was not built on oil wealth and is provided to all citizens) is one of them. The fact that there is a cultural Jewish home in a state that stretches from the Hula to Eilat and that this place is truly beautiful with dynamic people and towns is in and of itself a source for pride. While it might be a thrill for some to settle Judea and Samaria (or tacitly support those who do) that Zionist vision which places Israel on all the lands of the Bible will have to be left for the time of Moshiach.
{....}16 | AARON BENEZRA, SYRACUSE, NY, USA, Thursday Jan 01, 2009 RE#4 - DRDAN - "WHO'S PERSECUTING WHO?" Do you mean to suggest that Israel is persecuting Hamas? You must be blind! Go to Sderot and live there for a while! See how your nerves hold up from day to day, wondering if 15 seconds is time enough for you to run into a shelter to avoid the Qassam rocket that, like a lottery ticket, you may just win! Better yet, enter your own negotiations with Hamas; perhaps you are the reasonable one to whom Hamas will also be reasonable and acknowledge Israel's right to exist and all that is meant by that including the safe, healthy freedom of Gilad Shalit!
17 | Joe, New York, Thursday Jan 01, 2009 To Post #4 "drdan, canada": I'm trying to understand you're post. You say "Hamas can make the lives of *some* Israelis utterly miserable..." are you trying to say they do????? Are you just stating their capability's?????? We all know they've launched thousands of rockets into Israel which have killed MANY innocent men women and children! What do you want Israel to do, tell the the suffering orphans and widows that we're sorry but there's nothing we could do because Hamas doesn't have the capability's to whip us ALL off the map???? Explain!!! I'm just trying to understand.
18 | Gábor Fränkl Budapest, Hungary, Thursday Jan 01, 2009 Dear Author, Although I am a diaspora Jew, I perfectly understand the gist (and the desperation) of your post. I fully agree. I am convinced this description applies to the great majority of the Jews "outside" whose only source of information is the one-sided, seriously biased, and anti-semitic media. Well done! The majority of Jewish youth in my native Hungary for example has indeed NO identity - I am acutely aware of this problem, if this can be called a problem any longer. They have no identity and no spine unfortunately. Fränkl Gábor
19 | Gábor Fränkl, Thursday Jan 01, 2009 Oh and if I failed to appreciate enough I do now: THIS ARTICLE WAS TO THE POINT AND SIMPLY BRILLIANT! (But one thing is clear: those whom this justified outburst REALLY pertains to are those Jews, who live in societies, which are challenged by the swelling number of Muslim (and other) immigrants primarily in the West. This does NOT apply to those diaspora Jews whom are NOT targeted by the "Israel-thing", and they are mostly in post-communist Central-Eastern Europe. One thing you overlook: Jews in Poland, Hungary, Slovakia,the Czech Republic are incomperably much secure than those in W Europe!
20 | Jeff, Thursday Jan 01, 2009 Not all Diaspora Jews are what you accuse us of. I happen to agree with you and many others do too. By the same token, it appears that Israel has a significant number of its own citizenry that should read your article. The difference being, they are there, and that makes it even more difficult to understand.
21 | David Jerusalem/Philadephia, Thursday Jan 01, 2009 Jeremy Cardash, Phenomenal article, as an American Jew that moved to Israel and Joined the army I appreciate your view on Some of the Diaspora Jews, as well as your conviction and steadfast belief in Israel's need to defend itself. The world needs to start asking the Arab world why these people are so destructive? Why instead of using their money and resources to create a stable life for their people, they use them for terror and violence? Why the Arab Nations do not care for the Palestinians but rather use their plight as a tool for propoganda against Israel and the Western World?
22 | Tim, Ottawa, Canada, Thursday Jan 01, 2009 Mr. Cardash - I am merely a secular Protestant but your article provides the kind of hard truth that would aspire others to want to be Jewish. Good job on your article and please know that one doesn't have to be Jewish to love and support Israel and its people. I know - I do. I promote it wherever I go. Israel has many things I wish were transportable to the society in which I live - proving we can all learn from each other.
23 | Peter Bochner, Wayland, Mass., Thursday Jan 01, 2009 In the past week the Boston Globe has printed several letters from hand-wringing Jews expressing the sentiment "I'm so ashamed to be Jewish because of what Israel is doing to the poor inhabitants of Gaza instead of negotiating with the people's elected party of Hamas." They use the Globe's letters column as a podium to proclaim their liberal lunacy and express solidarity with terrorists. It makes me furious. Thank you Jeremy for writing this and G-d bless and protect the Israeli troops.
24 | concerned former democrat. USA, Thursday Jan 01, 2009 Great article. I am not Jewish but I support Israel. Those that are naive don't see this as the latest installment of the Crusades with steady encroachment of Islamist Jihadists throughout Europe,Asia,Africa and America. This is a time for Christians and Jews to unite...out of self preservation. I am praying for Israel and refuse to drink the politically popular Muslim Koolaide. Muslim extremists have made their intentions clear. This is a war on the West and it is that simple. Israel has the right and duty to defend herself.
25 | Alan, Japan, Thursday Jan 01, 2009 The only winners in the conflict are the media. Neither the Israelis nor the Palestinians can win and it seems that both sides have came to terms with the situation. If neither side is willing to move and both sides are willing to kill then large numbers of dead bodies and a tidal wave of hatred will inevitably ensue. To the West, Israel is a useful thorn in the side of Islam. A thorn which changed dimension when OPEC raised the price of oil and Islam redeveloped a little clout. If Israelis/Muslims cannot stop killing each other, other countries think 'better there than here' & life goes on.
{...}
45 | David, Friday Jan 02, 2009 I am sick and tired of the need to be liked at the expense of survival. Jews need to be unashamed about survival for the world cares little about Jewish blood. Israeli or otherwise. When Moses was in the Sinai, the Hebrews wandered through the desert until the generations that sinned died out, then they entered, so the bible states. Today Hamas and PLO entitities created a brainwashed generation to hate and a generation of Arabs have been raised educated to hate the very existence of Jews in Israel. A ponzi scheme of sorts supported with new hate filled recruits., FIGHT TO SURVIVE
46 | Frank Johnson--Watertown NY, Friday Jan 02, 2009 As an American Protestant I continue to be amazed by Jewish Americans who seem to feel that Israelies are the occupiers, the aggressors, and the evil doers. These people have been blinded by listening to left wing college(many Arab Palestinian) professors who continue to spout anti-Jewish propaganda in Middle Eastern Departments Studies departments at American univiersities funded by Arab Nations. They have been brain-washed by the media to feel that Jewish people should feel guilty about having a country of their own. Enough, many Americans like myself support you and wish you the best.
47 | Jay, Friday Jan 02, 2009 this is a worldwide problem of "2 sidedness" western societies always feel that there are 2 sides to a story and that you have to show both of them, once this happens you allow for an understanding of "the other side" which in this case was already hijacked by terrorists named Hamas. sometimes there is really only 1 side, i mean 1 side of truth and peace. I dont think anyone could argue that Osama Bin Laden has a point? and is justified? . so how can you argue that Hamas has a valid point to attack israeli children? there is no justification for Terrorism. they are blinded by 2 sidedness
{...}
51 | Jay L USA, Friday Jan 02, 2009 Jermey Cardash...There are a few Jews who are "lefty" way out there..but here in the USA most, in fact, support Israel wholeheartedly. I understand your concern about these "embarrased" (self hating) Jews. But we Jews couldnt have survived 4000 years of pogroms without a real religious or cultural strong desire to remain Jews! I don't like the Chomsky's of this world either...but you in Israel have your "lefty" jerks too. And as for this new attack on Gaza ..Im all for it. I dont know what in heck your Israelis were waiting for...were you "embarrased"! Go get em..Jeremey!
52 | LaevusManus, Australia, Friday Jan 02, 2009 This is clearly right wing dribble.
{...}
64 | Paulo Costa, Friday Jan 02, 2009 Take ordinary Palestians into account The problem with Israeli policy towards the Palestinians is that you only see your enemies, you never think of the ordinary Palestinian that could try to live a normal live only if he/she was nor hindered by lack of jobs, no free movement no acceptance of democratic elections by outsiders... Yes, you should be embarrassed of making living in gaza and West bank like living in Hell, like living in a Jewish ghetto of the past.. Why do not you try to reach for the ordinary palestinian and treat him like a human being? Hamas would have much less support
65 | D.S. N.Y., Friday Jan 02, 2009 Please know that many of us Diaspora Jews support Israel 100%.At least 100%of the people with whom I grew up, in the Modern Orthodox Jewish Community on the South Shore of Long Island, N.Y. We know the historical truth, and the present reality. I am on Israel's side , period. Im Eshkachech Yerushaliyam, Tishkach Yemini. And for Yossie, to where are you going to run when the next Hitler, Ye'mach Sh'emo, comes to slaughter us all?Are you hiding in some Yeshiva in Israel shirking your army duty and leaving that to some "Chiloni?" Thank you and G-d bless you to our righteous Gentile Friends.
66 | Manny, Chicago, Friday Jan 02, 2009 Mr. Cardash, I fully agree with your analysis. I am an Israeli living in the US, and I am surprised to find so many American Jews thinking the way you describe. They have no compassion for their brothers, but a lot of it for Palestinians, Iraqis, Darfur, Bosnia, etc. If Israel is destroyed, they will cry crocodile tears, and blame Israel for it. These Jews are maybe Jews by birth, but they have nothing Jewish in their soul. They will disappear in one generation or two. This is the curse of the Galut.
67 | Jeff - New York CIty, Friday Jan 02, 2009 Excellent piece. To the Author: there are "diaspora" Jews that live in Israel as well as in the Diaspora. Look at Haaretz, the Universities, etc. As for the Khazar canard, I would simply point out that whereas some of the Khazars certainly did join the other Jews of Eastern Europe, the idea that this East Asian group of Huns became the nation of Ashkenaic Jews is absurd culturally, historically and genetically. Conspiracy theories are fun, but they mostly act to conceal other agendas. In this case, one of delegitimization of the Jewish People.
{..}
71 | Don, Charolette, NC, USA, Friday Jan 02, 2009 I'm a Christian from the so called Bible Belt. G-d is fulfilling his promise to Israel. I expect the Temple to be built soon and for Israel to control all the land G-d gave you. As for me, I wish I could be with the ground troops when they enter Gaza. I am proud of you Israel and I suport you. Shalom Aleichem
72 | Saskian - USA, Friday Jan 02, 2009 Mr. Cardash, your article was fabulous - your thinking could and should be applied right here in the USA. I am an evangelical Christian - understand that evangelicals in the USA support Israel - we have always supported you. We thank the Lord you exist. I have to laugh at some of the responses that say "most Israeli immigrants are from - " - they are from somewhere else because the Jews were dispersed and they are the children, great grandchildren, etc., of the people that were dispersed - their grandfathers couldn't come back because they were killed but they are coming back.
73 | Coltrane Walker USA, Friday Jan 02, 2009 If I were you I would not want to hear some US gentile say what I am going to say, which is: your essay precludes peace. In the midst of bombings, wars with Hizbullah & Hamas, the Iranian & syrian threats, Fatah's incompetence, etc I +totally+ agree with you about self-hatred, temporizing and anything other than total single-minded unity being suicidal, esp b/c I'm sitting here in the US with no bombs and lots of media propoganda. Probably b/c of this, I pray and believe peace will come for you someday --- and the pacificsm you deride will be as essential then as militarism is now...
74 | Paul, Rochester NY USA, Friday Jan 02, 2009 Nice article, and very true. I am a mostly liberal American Jew. If the Palestinians were my peaceful poor neighbors, I would want to help them. Once they use lethal force in my direction, then I want to stop them. I no longer care about their poverty. The only moral response to the use of lethal force against us is to stop the aggressors any way possible. The terrorist organizations are causing the suffering of the Palestinians, not Israel.
75 | Dan, Friday Jan 02, 2009 This would be a stronger article if it was written from Hebron. It makes for stirring prose to claim people are either for or against "us," but that begs the question of exactly what "us" represents: the settlers? the occupation? We are all against the rocket violence, which seems in 2009 to now be systemic- how did we get here, from a simpler world 60 years ago? Something you must understand is that building a world view and approach based on positioning an entire religion, all the people, as your enemies, at all times, and all their secular governments, has led to failure. You own Gaza.
76 | Rob, Israel, Friday Jan 02, 2009 And thankyou Adam and thankyou Shlomi! I have known Adam and Shlomi for more than 12 years. As a good friend of their mother, I've watched these boys grow up. Great boys, kind hearts. Anyone would be proud to know them. Now Adam is 19 and Shlomi 20. Anyone in Israel immediately knows what this means. Adam is sitting on the border with Gaza,, Shlomi is still at his base. We, that know them, are nervous. These beautiful jewish boys are sitting in the cold, holding their guns and protecting us, our way of life, our existence. Thankyou a million times.
77 | Margaret Wade, Friday Jan 02, 2009 I am a gentile from Canada who completely agrees with your article. Well written.
78 | Stephen Friedman, Friday Jan 02, 2009 Your article makes what, from my perspective, is a totally false assumption, namely that the Jews of the Diaspora do not stand solidly with the State of Israel in this, its latest trauma. You are too easily confused by a small number of Hollywood pedantics. They do not represent the vast majority of Jews who stand solidly with Israel at this hour and at all hours when she is under attack. We may cry, as do many Israelis for the tragic and wasteful loss of life in Gaza, but we put the blame for that tragic squarely where it belongs; on Hamas.
79 | Bill Bender, Friday Jan 02, 2009 Apparently if Israel was being destroyed by Hamas that would be an acceptable level of "response" by Israel according to the US media and others. Israel may be the only country left in the civilized world that has the moral fiber to deliver itself from true evil. God Bless Israel!
80 | Zelda Philadelphia, PA USA, Friday Jan 02, 2009 As most people in the world today, American Jews do not know their own history, the history of Israel and the history of the US. To answer #2....I know the history of the Khazars but not all Eastern European Jewry are their descendants. Many travel across Europe-West to East during the Inquisition. One must read the history of the area to fully appreciate the situation. Remeber ther British made promises to bothe Jew and Arab for the territory. The Mufti of Jeruselam had Muslims attach Jews long before Hitler and was his guest during WWII.
81 | Ray USA, Friday Jan 02, 2009 Joeseph Wheeler, Part1 You are citing a myth that "most Jews are descendants of Khazrs. This idea as popularized in early 20 Century by some Jews trying to escape the racist antisemitic sentiment. As if saying "look we are not Semites, we are Khazars". This myth has been thoroughly from every possible angle: In recent years most decisively by the DNA research. The Y-chromosome studies show European Jews very mots closely related to Syrians and other Arabs around Israel, clearly proving the Semitic origins of European Jews.
82 | Ray, Friday Jan 02, 2009 Joeseph Wheeler Part2 Besides the Semitic origins of Jews, a national identity does not need to depend on ethnicity. It is a cultural identity. For example Italian and Polish Americans can speak of the framers of the Constitution as "Our Founding Fathers", even though none of these "Founding Fathers" were Italian, or Polish. Much more so with Jews: for 2000 years of Diaspora Jews have stayed connected with the land of Israel. They continued to celebrate events from Israeli history, and regard Land of Israel as their home and Jerusalem as their capitol.
83 | Deborah, Friday Jan 02, 2009 After reading Caroline Glick's comment 'that Israel has decided to lose the War.I wonder why there is 9.000 Reservists called up and each day the enemies of Israel organize anf inflame their populations. Why start something and not finish it? However I have always supported Israel and do so now.My thoughts and prayers are with you all. Shalom.
84 | Paula Friedman, Parkdale, Oregon, USA, Friday Jan 02, 2009 I have worked for my Jewish communities, here in the western U.S., for the past 20 years, and I have spent considerable time in Israel and am aware of its minuscule borders, its precarious position; I have known Holocaust survivors; I have encountered antisemitism. Nevertheless, bombing Gaza senseless remains senseless. It alienates all support for Israel. It creates more terrorism in reaction. And it is murder, killing innocents. It also extends realistic fear to paranoia, and kills realistic hope. As a Jew, I am not embarrassed--I am horrified.
85 | Charlotte, Israel, Friday Jan 02, 2009 This was a fantastic article. I was a diaspora jew but recently- four months ago made aliyah to Israel from the UK. A nation which is incredibly anti- zionist and ever increasingly in the media anti-semitic. I could not bare to watch the news coverage of Israel there. Watching the BBC now is painful enough. I wish that this point of view could be shown to the rest of the world, that Gaza has had billions of $'s pumped in to build a society, but they would rather build rockets to send into Israel. Of course that never gets reported in the international media. If only articles like this were!